Embark Studios is facing criticism after replacing real esports commentators with AI-generated voices in an official highlight video for The Finals’ Grand Major tournament. The video, which featured the game’s AI commentators Scotty and June instead of the actual casters, has since been deleted following backlash from the esports community.
The controversy is particularly interesting considering Embark has been moving in the opposite direction with ARC Raiders, replacing AI-generated dialogue with real voice acting following criticism.
In Brief
- Embark Studios replaced human esports commentary with AI-generated voices in a highlight reel for The Finals Grand Major APAC Closed Qualifiers.
- Professional casters criticized the decision, claiming the AI commentators even repeated some of their original commentary.
- Embark apologized, removed the video, and canceled similar AI-narrated recaps planned for other regions.
- The controversy comes after Embark began replacing AI voices with human recordings in ARC Raiders.
The Finals Esports Casters Speak Out After Being Replaced by AI

The controversy began when Embark Studios published a highlight reel covering the APAC Closed Qualifiers for The Grand Major, an official esports tournament for The Finals.
Instead of using the original commentary from the matches, Embark featured Scotty and June, the game’s fictional announcers whose dialogue is generated using AI-powered text-to-speech technology.
However, the decision frustrated the professional casters who had spent months covering the competitive scene.
On November 16, esports commentator Proto / Kai expressed his disappointment on X, explaining that he, TheeHyperactive, and Bluepanda had dedicated significant time to the tournament.
“After 4 cycles, open/closed quals, the time, effort, passion and emotion myself @TheeHyperactive and @bluepanda_casts put in. We get replaced by two Ai casters who even quote us :/ I get they are apart of the game but yikes. Thanks @reachthefinals”
The original post quickly attracted attention, with other esports commentators joining the criticism.
Marvel Rivals caster LemonKiwi also condemned the decision, arguing that the original commentators deserved recognition for their work.
The controversy has raised concerns about the future of professional esports casting and whether AI-generated commentary could eventually replace paid talent.
Embark Studios Apologizes and Deletes the AI Commentary Video
Following the backlash, Embark Studios acknowledged that excluding the original casters was a mistake.
In a statement provided to IGN, the developer explained that it wanted to use Scotty and June to introduce more players to The Finals’ competitive scene.
Embark clarified that its team selected footage from the original broadcast and wrote a new script for the AI commentators.
The studio admitted that leaving out the original talent was the wrong decision.
As a result, Embark removed the APAC highlight reel and confirmed that similar AI-commentated videos planned for the Americas and EMEA regions would no longer be released in their original format.
Oscar Lundberg, who works on competitive experience and community at Embark, also apologized publicly.
However, some of the original commentators remain frustrated. Bluepanda told IGN that the apology did little to address the larger issue of how esports talent is treated.
Proto also called for stronger industry protections, including contracts that would prevent the unauthorized use of commentators’ voices in generative AI.
Embark Is Replacing AI Voices With Real Actors in ARC Raiders, So Why the Opposite in The Finals?

Perhaps the most confusing part of this controversy is Embark’s recent approach to voice acting in ARC Raiders.
Earlier in 2026, Embark confirmed that it had started replacing AI-generated dialogue with recordings from professional voice actors.
Embark CEO Patrick Sรถderlund even acknowledged that professional actors deliver better results than AI-generated performances.
More recently, reports suggested that ARC Raiders had re-recorded all its quest dialogue using real voice actors, although the full extent of those changes remains unverified.
Embark has also invested in more detailed performance capture for ARC Raiders, including improvements to Celeste’s facial expressions and character model to better reflect the performance of her voice actor, Diana Gardner.
So, while Embark has been putting greater emphasis on human performances in ARC Raiders, it decided to replace actual esports commentary with AI-generated dialogue in The Finals’ promotional material.
It’s worth clarifying that Scotty and June’s synthetic voices are based on recordings from paid professional voice actors. There is no confirmed evidence that Embark trained these AI voices on the esports casters themselves.
Still, using AI commentary in a highlight reel featuring matches originally covered by professional casters has understandably raised questions about the value placed on their work.
The Finals AI Controversy Raises Bigger Concerns for Esports
AI-generated commentary has been part of The Finals since launch, and Embark has continued expanding the feature.
In October 2026, the developer introduced Dynamic Commentary, allowing Scotty and June to reference player usernames and react to specific moments during matches.
However, using the same technology to narrate actual esports matches while excluding the original commentators has created a very different reaction.
Although Embark has reversed its decision, the incident has sparked a wider conversation about the future of esports broadcasting.
With The Grand Major approaching, the controversy also puts additional pressure on Embark to demonstrate its commitment to the human talent helping build The Finals’ competitive community.
